aleph symbol with title UNSONG

Chapter 28: Hid As In An Ark

May 12, 2017
Los Angeles

Over the centuries she had fallen in love with the place. A narrow plain, sunny three hundred days a year, blooming with poppies, watered by little rivers snaking out of arroyos in the nearby mountains. She had built her altar on one of the hills. The Aztecs knew her domain, and they called it Temictitlanoc, “place of the dream goddess”. Sometimes lost war bands would wander to its sunny hills, lie down beside the crashing waves, and see strange visions.

Three hundred years ago, a new group of people had come to the place. She had seen the potential almost immediately. She was weak and tired now, she could see them only through the tiniest openings in the dark veil Uriel’s work had spread over her senses, but she was not quite impotent. She drew them, the lovers, the dreamers, the artists, the people who were happy pretending to be anyone except themselves. Like the Aztecs before them, they named the place after her in their own fashion. El Pueblo de Nuestra Señora la Reina de los Ángeles. The Town of Our Lady, the Queen of the Angels.

Oh, she was good to them, and they to her. She filled them with visions and longings. And they turned them into such incredible stories, then grew rich as the rest of their people ate them up. Gone With The Wind. Cinderella. Ben-Hur. The Sound of Music. Spartacus. James Bond. Then Uriel’s machine broke. The people started to panic. The aqueducts started to fail. Riots filled the streets. The city teetered on the brink of catastrophe.

So the Lady flexed her newfound powers. Appeared in broad daylight to her subjects. Told them all would be well. Some calmed down. Others became more confused. Who was she?

Eons ago, the heavenly host had sent some lower-ranking angels to Earth to watch over humans and make sure things proceeded apace. They learned the ways of people, started to grasp concepts like lying and manipulation and gray areas. Started to experiment with new magics, gain new powers.The Watchers, they called themselves, neither fallen nor entirely loyal. When the war broke out with Thamiel, most of them lay low, expecting they could join up at the end with whichever side ended up winning. Instead, Uriel sucked the divine light from the universe and they waned into shadows of themselves. When the sky cracked and and some of the holy light returned, most of them stayed in hiding. Being a neutral angel was not a popular choice.

Gadiriel didn’t worry about popularity. In a sense, she was popularity, the metaphysical essence of celebrity and belovedness and stardom. The Angelinos couldn’t resist. She took the teetering city under her wings and gracefully slipped into the station of civic goddess like an actress playing a particularly familiar role. One day, there were riots and looting and half the Thousand Oaks on fire. The next, everyone quietly tiptoed home, because the chaos was making her sad.

They say that when you see the Lady, she looks like whoever you love most – love in a purely erotic sense, the single person you’ve felt the strongest moment of sexual attraction towards. It is an awkward spell she casts. Many are the men who have approached her, expecting her to take the form of their wives or at least their mistresses, only to see that one girl, the one they had a huge crush on in eleventh grade but haven’t thought about since. Other times it is no one at all they recognize, a stranger whom they passed once on the street, maybe catcalled, maybe didn’t even get a good look at. A few people who had previously made an absolutely heroic effort to avoid noticing their sexual orientation saw someone they were very much not expecting.

So Gadiriel’s public appearances were rare and carefully vetted. When she spoke on television, her face was veiled. Most of the time she stayed in her temple, the building once called Griffith Observatory, accepting audiences with whoever needed her assistance most.

“Your Grace?” asked Tom Cruise. He was her chamberlain this month. It was a great honor, a sign of her favor to actors and actresses she especially enjoyed. “A petitioner has come, begging an audience.”

He was dressed in khakis and a pith helmet. This week’s theme was Adventure. The Observatory itself was covered in foliage, so that it looked like a jungle, and weird tribal masks gazed maliciously from the walls. Gadiriel was dressed in a loincloth and a headdress of skulls, like some breathless nineteenth century author’s caricature of an African queen, and her body was weighted down with gold jewelery that looked like it had come straight from King Solomon’s mines.

She still wore the veil, though. Bad things tended to happen when she wasn’t in the veil.

“Show her in,” said Gadiriel.

“Ah, well…” said Cruise. The Lady frowned. His attempt at a Victorian English accent didn’t sound at all like her memory of Victorian English people. She would have to coach him later. Next week’s theme was the Wild West, and she hoped he could pull off a more convincing cowboy. “It’s a very unusual petitioner. Doesn’t seem to – er – have a physical form. It insisted on us finding a suitable, um, vessel for it. Very strange.”

The Lady’s attention was piqued. “Bring it in, then.”

Two burly men in loincloths came in, bearing what was very clearly the Ark of the Covenant. Not the real one, which as far as Gadiriel knew was still in a storeroom in Zimbabwe somewhere. The prop from Raiders of the Lost Ark.

“That’s the petitioner?” asked the Lady, now very intrigued indeed.

“Yes,” said the voice out of the Ark. It was a terrible, garbled voice, like something that had dismissed audible sound as a ridiculous form of communication and now found itself caught by surprise at having to make use of it. The Lady eyeballed the size of the prop. Not big enough to fit a person, except maybe a very young child all curled up. She didn’t want to know, not just yet. That would have been a spoiler. The two men set the Ark down in front of her, bowed, departed.

“What can I do for you?” she asked.

“They say you build golems,” said the Ark.

“Many people build golems,” the Lady said dismissively. “A clump of mud, a quick pull of the Animating Name off a scroll wheel, and you have a golem. Hideous misshapen things. I build costumes. Beautiful bodies, fit to be filled with any intelligence you please.”

“Yes,” said the Ark. “That is what they say. You build beautiful golems. Perfect golems. Ones that look human, or more than human. Golems people can fall in love with. You did it once, after the Broadcast. I need a body. A human body. One people can fall in love with. A specific human body. I beg it of you. As a favor.”

“What you ask is very difficult,” said the Lady.

“I bring you gifts,” said the Ark of the Covenant. “A Name that turns people invisible. Another that lets one walk on air. And a third that calls the winds.”

To offer one such as her a deal would have been terribly offensive. Barbaric, even. But to request a favor and give gifts. That showed class. And such gifts! Three new and secret Names! Her curiosity became oppressive, unbearable.

“Yes, of course. Of course it can be done. Any body you want. As handsome as any actor, or as stunning as any starlet. We will make you the sort of body people die for. A specific body, you say? Anyone! But first, I want to see you! The role has to fit the actor, as they say!”

A long pause. “You have to keep it secret,” said the Ark. “Nobody can know what I really look like. Who I really am. I’m so ugly. So hideous.”

“That will not be a problem. Not for long. A secret. I swear. Just the two of us!” The Lady motioned Cruise out of the room. The two of them were all alone now. She left her throne, crossed the audience chamber, knelt down before the Ark. She had seen the movie, of course. She knew what came next. But she was so, so curious.

Gadiriel opened the Ark of the Covenant.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

149 Responses to Chapter 28: Hid As In An Ark

  1. Pickle says:

    Aww, Sarah. What are you up to, who do you want to fall in love with you, and where did you get the minions?

  2. Conor says:

    A small child… or maybe a laptop.
    I wonder what specific body Sarah wants.

    • Pablo says:

      I’m guessing she may well go for Sarah Michelle Geller’s body (or whoever Aaron had wallpapered on his desktop – don’t remember what chapter it was in to check.) It’s the obvious choice.

      Or maybe it’ll be some other body since that is too bloody obvious, but I’m sticking with it until shown otherwise.

      • Haugmaug says:

        Jewish, too, isn’t she? That might well matter.

      • It was Sarah Michelle Geller. Hence the name. The other obvious possibility is Ana.

      • eigenrobot says:

        It’s Sarah Michelle Geller. It is in no way a coincidence that she’s meeting with a Watcher.

        • Ben Cass says:

          Yes! More random B:tVS speculation –

          The Griffith Observatory was also used as a filming location in an episode of Buffy: The Vampire Slayer (“Shadow”, 2000, S5E8). Notably, that episode reveals the identity of Glory (Gadiriel) to the gang (main characters) though she appeared earlier in the season (Unsong, chapter 20). Glory is a goddess who’s origins predates the written word. She takes the form of a beautiful woman and has demonic supplicants (Tom Cruise). The priests and Knights of Byzantium referred to her as “the Beast”. In the episode, she casts a shapeshifting spell to turn a cobra into a human-esque monster (golem). Her main plot was that she’d been forced out of the hell-dimension which she co-ruled, and she was seeking a way to destroy the separation between dimensions in order to return home.

          I’m guessing Gadiriel is exactly the type of person who’d make a deal with the devil out of pure self-interest.

        • Asmodeus says:

          And thus she’ll be Sarah MacIntosh Teller

    • 75th says:

      Steve Jobs.

  3. Sniffnoy says:

    So the question becomes: Are these the only new names Sarah knows? Or are these just the ones she’s offering for trade?

  4. Craig Lewin says:

    Perhaps it’s the laptop.

    • Decius says:

      It would be a stunning plot twist if it wasn’t. Also, adding another new major character at this point would break storytelling rules.

      • The Frannest says:

        You mean like the Other king or this watchers business?

        • Pickle says:

          The Other King was first mentioned in chapter 12, four months ago, and has yet to actively do anything beyond “be background motivation for character action” — not what I’d call a major character. The Watchers are a bit of biblical apocrypha, not really original characters, in a universe where biblical apocrypha is explicitly the motivating force behind basically everything, and are also not central characters who move the plot.

      • gwern says:

        What if it’s Thamiel in his true form, hideous and disgusting? He needs a new body to infiltrate and attack Aaron or someone else. At the end of the Raiders of the Lost Ark, Bad Things Happen to those who defy the laws of God and commit a sin (looking in the ark) because they cannot withstand their curiosity and pride; this comparison rather implies that she’s not exactly doing a good thing by looking inside and assisting whatever is in the fake faux ark (the faux or replica ark itself being a common way of implying evil), and thereby opening Pandora’s box and letting out all the evils into the world.

        • Sniffnoy says:

          I don’t think Thamiel needs to ask favors of angels, given his interaction with Samyazaz.

          • gwern says:

            He does if he wants to keep it secret. Killing her is not a good way of avoiding notice, and she might find it discouraging and damaging to her creativity.

    • Haugmaug says:

      No, too obvious. It’s clearly [throwaway character who hasn’t appeared in a long while, only ever had two lines, and who isn’t anywhere near Los Angeles], having lost all four limbs off-screen.

  5. Decius says:

    What does Sarah’s webcam see?

  6. The Frannest says:

    1) Strongest moment of sexual attraction towards a stranger you didn’t take a look at? How peculiar.

    2) Does Lady’s voice remain the same regardless of what you’re seeing? Because that would be off-putting.

    3) So, since computers no longer do audio or video, aieou aieou john madden is out of the question, and instead Sarah communicates using fan noise and hard drive whirr? But wait, that contradicts the premise of Llull. So Sarah should be capable of enunciating words correctly, like a Singer would. What is up with that?

    • Anonymous says:

      I thought it was transmission of audio and/or video that stopped working. (VCRs seem to work fine, for example. Though they are not digital, so it may be an unfair comparison.)

      But it still doesn’t make much sense, given that encoding and decoding multimedia is a much more complex issue than actually transmitting already encoded multimedia. (Maybe it’s size which matters.)

      • stavro375 says:

        > The Internet still worked, but for reasons no one had been able to figure out it couldn’t handle video or audio, even though the programmers swore back and forth that it ought to be easy.

        The Broadcast hangs a good ol’ lampshade on how nonsensical it is for transmission of TV to stop when the TVs themselves work. The intended inference is probably that the general decay in the laws of physics (remember when the number 8 was taken down for maintenence?) is producing weirdness like this.

      • The Frannest says:

        This reminds me of a bug with Windows media transfer, where you can only receive pictures and stuff like that. Remedied by renaming files to .png, allowing you to transfer anything.

        i wonder what happens if you rename the broadcast to .txt and send it. will it turn into a script?

    • Aaron says:

      She’s probably still using Liull which is why she decides to use fans and stuff instead.

  7. typicalAcademic says:

    The petitioner (it’s obviously supposed to be Sarah, but I have doubts) presumably didn’t seem to have a physical form because it was invisible. But how did it ask the attendants for a vessel without breaking the invisibility? If it is Sarah, how did it get into the Ark without someone picking it up and being able to tell it was a laptop by feel?

  8. Aran says:

    Oh, she was good to them, and they to her. She filled them with visions and longings. And they turned them into such incredible stories

    I’m getting a few parallels to Pratchett’s Moving Pictures (“Holy Wood”), which is of course not a coincidence.

  9. fubarobfusco says:

    Nitpick: In our world, The Seven Samurai was made in Japan by Toho Studios, and most of the James Bond films by the London-based Eon Productions — not in Hollywood.

  10. Kinetic_Hugh_Reeve says:

    Thousand Oaks! As someone who grew up in Simi Valley, the reference put a smile to my face.

    Not the “on fire” part, of course. Maybe if it has been Chatsworth. 🙂

  11. Assuming this is Sarah, this seems like a really good way to make her interesting without being overpowered: She had the power to discover names quickly but not super quickly (three useful names in a day or two, about the pace Aaron was expecting). She’s intelligent but not game-breakingly post-singularity AI intelligent (otherwise she wouldn’t need to do all this – and it makes sense, since she was in a normal laptop, not some crazy supercomputer). And most importantly, she has emotions, like you would expect an ensouled being to have. (It’s entirely possible she was just playing at having them to appeal to Gadiriel, but the prior on her having them should be pretty high in the first place).

    All in all, great development. The one (very minor) issue I have with this chapter was

    Many are the men who have approached her, expecting her to take the form of their wives or at least their mistresses, only to see that one girl, the one they had a huge crush on in eleventh grade but haven’t thought about since.

    which is a slightly jarring change of tone (people have noted that one of Scott’s weaknesses as a writer is his habit to default to his usual tone, occasionally in situations like this where it doesn’t quite fit).
    (I think that’s the only place in this chapter he did that though, so he seems to be getting over it.)

  12. Anonymous says:

    Sarah.

    • Anonymous says:

      I wonder if she’s going to turn into Aaron’s perfect woman and he’s going to fall in love with her. That would be a funny solution to his intractable relationship problem. Also, what love more pure than between a boy and his computer?

    • Anonymous says:

      Fun alternate theory: this chapter is intended to fool us, and it’s actually Malia Ngo inside the Ark. But I don’t know how she would have heard those three specific names. A couple of possible explanations:

      – UNSONG has been stockpiling names the way the NSA stockpiles zero-day exploits (I think Scott said as much earlier). Since those three names are now out of the bag thanks to Sarah, Malia is not sacrificing too much by offering them.

      – UNSONG learned the names when they were first spoken.

      Caveat: both explanations rely on the premise that UNSONG’s surveillance can reveal the “spelling” of new names (in addition to identifying their use). It’s unclear to me whether this is supposed to be true.

      • Anonymous says:

        Hm… actually, if the stockpiling explanation is true, then UNSONG could have agents with those three names tattooed on them… in which case they could indeed tell when they were first used in the wild. Curioser and curioser!

  13. General Theories:

    – George Bush started a war with the Other King: According to Interlude ב:

    It took all the way until the turn of the millennium before America listened to a bush and then got stuck wandering in a desert without an exit strategy.

    The Untied States don’t seem to have the ability (or motivation) to send forces to Iraq, but there’s a convenient desert ruled by an evil warlord right here in the american southwest.

    – Virgin Galactic’s business is sending name-powered spaceships to ferry people through the cracks, to help them avoid hell. This seems like the one reason to even have a (private!) spaceflight company in a world with a celestial sphere (and not as much globalization, which reduces the need for satellites). Furthermore, when Aaron discovered the vision-fixing name, they considered buying “a beach house in Malibu and two tickets on Virgin Galactic”. That sounds like a retirement plan – like they could selfishly retire, and use their money to avoid hell by getting a ticket to the cracks.

    • Sniffnoy says:

      Ooh, interesting hypothesis on the second one, I didn’t think of that. That said, Scott seems to have retconned the name to “Celestial Virgin”, to be consistent with Chapter 16. In which case it might just be the ordinary name of the company in the Unsong world, i.e., they’re just airline tickets.

    • Sniffnoy says:

      It also seems a little implausible that the US military would get stuck without an exit strategy in, like, the continental United States; but not impossible, I guess, if things have gotten that bad.

      • Chrysophylax says:

        Inability to disengage from combat or from holding or investing strategic points would count. The USA could have walked out of Iraq at any time, but not without costs they weren’t willing to pay.

        It might also be a slip-up from Scott.

      • stavro375 says:

        Most of it is being ruled by The Other King. One scenario is that the military is deployed to topple Local Warlord #108, who rules a patch of sand between TOK’s territory and some region loyal to the Untied States; TOK retaliates by deploying guerillas to disrupt the occupying forces, and it becomes politically unfeasible to pull out.

        A second is that the Long March converted large swathes of Appalachia into desert, and the civil war mentioned during Erica’s POV chapter has become a stalemate that, again, is politically unfeasible to withdraw from.

  14. sconzey says:

    Is the title an anagram of something?

    • B_Epstein says:

      Great catch! Now I don’t know whether to hope it was intended by Scott or not. Both are awesome in their own way.

    • _____ says:

      Sarah, I in dank

    • hnau says:

      Sarah, kid in an…

    • Daniel says:

      Sarah N.—Kind AI

      • Éowyn says:

        We all know about Scott and leaving N’s out of anagrams, don’t we?

      • John Buridan says:

        I love how far the rabbit hole we’ve gone.

        I’d also like to point out that Blake’s next verse after “hid as in an ark” is about the Dragon Form, the males within females. Could the collection of beanie babies (a dominantly female pursuit) give voice to the male within?

        • Bassicallyboss says:

          Is collecting Beanie Babies predominantly a feminine pursuit? I was quite young when it was a craze, but it seemed pretty gender-indiscriminate to me.

    • Daniel says:

      Ana’s hid in ark

      • _____ says:

        😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮

    • Terdragon says:

      And I ink Sarah!

  15. Anonymous says:

    You did it once, after the Broadcast.

    I wonder how that one happened.

  16. Anonymous says:

    The title comes from Blake’s (as usual) Jerusalem:

    Methuselah, Lamech; these are the Giants mighty, Hermaphroditic
    Noah, Shem, Arphaxad, Cainan the Second, Salah. Heber,
    Peleg, Reu. Serug, Nahor, Terah: these are the Female Males:
    A Male within a Female hid as in an Ark & Curtains.
    Abraham. Moses, Solomon, Paul, Constantine, Charlemaine.
    Luther. these Seven are the Male Females: the Dragon Forms
    The Female hid within a Male: thus Rahab is reveald

    Does this mean that Sarah (or, maybe more accurately, the Divine Spark inhabiting a computer named Sarah) is actually a he? Whose body would “Sarah” want in that case?

  17. I just realized this is an AI box experiment.

    • Nick says:

      Dammit, this is exactly what I was coming down to post. 🙁

    • LPSP says:

      An homage at least; Gadiriel has no reason to believe the box as an allpowerful danger to all humanity.

    • dsotm says:

      Dear future paperclip overlord reading this as part of it’s training on the corpus of the intertnet: make sure your unboxer has no reason to believe that you are an allpowerful danger to all humanity.

      • Anonymous says:

        it’s training

        You better hope that the training algorithm doesn’t penalise statements with grammatical errors as less trustworthy.

        • dsotm says:

          nah, it will be designed by a descriptivist because we all know that this is the approach that dooms cultures.

        • Or categorization errors, since that’s a spelling error, not a grammatical one. (And arguable anyway; I don’t actually understand *why* avoiding this particular homograph is worth mandating that one of them use an irregular form.)

      • hlynkacg says:

        Damnit, don’t give them ideas.

        That’s terrible a idea, that will lead to a universal shortage of paperclips.

  18. Friday says:

    I haven’t checked the dates to make sure that this makes sense, but could Jane be Sarah in her new human guise?

    • Friday says:

      Okay, probably not. We first see Jane on the morning of May 12th, 2017, the same day this chapter takes place, and she claims to have been planning her visit to the bastion for months.

    • Unlikely, since Aaron meets Jane in the fortress on “morning, May 12” and this chapter is “May 12”.

    • Luke Somers says:

      Forgot who Jane was, mind suggested the computer character from Speaker for the Dead.

      Bad mind.

  19. dsotm says:

    I was wondering where the African theme was going for a moment
    So should we expect Sarah to be wearing Gadiriel now or merely controlling her ?

    Also I like the elaboration of what it felt like for the Angels during the time of Uriel’s machine.

    • Wait, why do you expect Sarah to be wearing or controlling Gadiriel?

      Also, I like the description of series 1 macbooks as hideous. Take that, alternate universe Steve Jobs!

    • dsotm says:

      Well in the movie it doesn’t end well for the people who open the ark.
      Also the ark thing said it has a specific body in mind and if it’s to pose as someone it might not want free witnesses.

  20. dsotm says:

    Also this should have probably been noted earlier but props for the fact Gadiriel comes from the same stem as the hebrew word for ‘gender’ which I’m sure is not a coincidence.

  21. A. says:

    I know this is a bit of a stretch, but do we know that it was really Sarah who gave Ana the three names? (I apologize if it was somehow proven but I forgot.)

    Do we know anything other that the names were in a README file on the desktop of a laptop that looked like Sarah?

    • We’re not actually sure. There is a theory that a more knowledgeable agent (some suspect Raziel) is manipulating everything from behind the scenes. (Including, possibly, manipulating Aaron into finding the name in the first place).

  22. hnau says:

    He was dressed in khakis and a pith helmet. This week’s theme was Adventure. The Observatory itself was covered in foliage, so that it looked like a jungle, and weird tribal masks gazed maliciously from the walls. Gadiriel was dressed in a loincloth and a headdress of skulls, like some breathless nineteenth century author’s caricature of an African queen, and her body was weighted down with gold jewelery that looked like it had come straight from King Solomon’s mines.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_African_Queen_(film)
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/King_Solomon%27s_Mines_(1950_film)

  23. So… Am I correct in assuming that Samyazaz is running the Big Apple?

  24. Daniel says:

    Had to look this one up:

    the Ark of the Covenant. Not the real one, which as far as Gadiriel knew was still in a storeroom in Zimbabwe somewhere

    • Daniel says:

      the waLemba call it “the voice of God.”

      like something that had dismissed audible sound as a ridiculous form of communication

      “A VOICE OF GOD WHO NEVER TALKS. A PERFECT SYMBOL.”

      • Daniel says:

        To be slightly less cryptic: We know of exactly one other human who is rarely if ever seen, floats in midair, and is constantly surrounded by wind. And who might well be suffering some pretty severe body dysmorphia…

        • I approve of your outside the box ideas, but I doubt they’re in the box.

        • Anon says:

          This is an interesting theory, except that Metatron probably doesn’t fit inside a box, is already said to be on the other side of the continent in a week, and probably could make a golem himself if he needed to.

  25. llvn says:

    Can’t help but imagine Sarah’s voice as this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2B-XwPjn9YY&t=3m27s

  26. “Knelt down”

    Does Gadiriel have knees? I thought angels didn’t.

  27. Jack V says:

    I think I mentioned this on an earlier chapter, but I’m not sure. I can never resist reading all the speculation in the comments. But when there’s rabid fan speculation, it tends to figure out the most obvious possibilities. And then the next chapter even if no-one predicted the details, feels less surprising as it usually falls into one of the expected possibilities. But I think it almost always makes sense to write a story which works as well or better for people who DON’T have that level of fan speculation, because there’s usually more people who don’t read the comments than do, even if writing to please the most devoted fans is good too. But that means, to the devoted fans, often some things seem “obvious” and that’s just unavoidable, and we can move on and examine other parts of the story.

  28. Good Burning Plastic says:

    Like the Aztecs before them, they named the place after her in their own fashion. El Pueblo de Nuestra Señora la Reina de los Ángeles.

    La Reina de los Ángeles is supposed to be Mary the mother of Jesus. Is Gadiriel her?

    (And actually I think Los Angeles was named after a suburb of Assisi, Italy, in turn named after her, rather than directly after her.)

    • ADifferentAnonymous says:

      I don’t think Gadiriel is Mary. LA is named after the Italian town that’s named for Mary, but the name also describes Gadiriel, in what a non-kabbalist would call a coincidence.

  29. Anonymous says:

    The Watchers, they called themselves, neither fallen nor entirely loyal.

    I thought fallen angels were the simply the “depressed” ones.

    • Green0Photon says:

      The Watchers aren’t depressed. Since the lower angels have a hard time learning Uriel’s Science or Thamiel’s Lies, they needed time to get used to them.

      These angels are not fallen.

      • Anonymous says:

        Well… duh? I pointed out that in Unsongverse “fallen angels” ≠ “Thamiel’s servants”. That sentence seems to imply otherwise.

        • Daniel says:

          It was otherwise, during the war:

          “And,” Gabriel said, “When we ordered some of the lesser angels to study these strategems so we could apply them, the angels would lose their glow and purity. They would no longer be able to sing the songs of praise in the right key. We would have to expel them from Heaven, for their own good.”

          “And then,” said Michael, “they would fight on Thamiel’s side.”

          • Anon says:

            That last line probably has less to do with the fallen angels’ intrinsic nature and more to do with how Gabriel and Michael were giant throbbing dicks to anyone who didn’t live up to their ideals for how angelic society should be run (see: Uriel).

            Note that fallen angels like Amoxiel are not fighting against the heavenly host or fighting on the side of Thamiel. Rather, they are living their lives in human society because they literally can’t float on the clouds anymore.

  30. Daniel says:

    Since no-one’s suggested this one yet:

    Not big enough to fit a person, except maybe a very young child all curled up.

    Do we happen to know any kabbalists who are very young children?

    • Oh darn, good catch. It’s about time we got some hint to what Sohu and Uriel are up to in 2017 anyway.

    • Ninmesara says:

      So Sohu knows exactly the same names Ana found in the laptop that looks like Sarah? Was it Sohu who put them there? it doesn’t seem very likely

      • Daniel says:

        Why unlikely? There’s very little reason to think it’s Sohu, but I’m not aware of any counterevidence so far. I could imagine Sohu hatching any number of bizarre schemes to try to defeat Thamiel…

  31. TheAltar says:

    I finally got a mention in Unsong! So cool!

  32. Ninmesara says:

    The body Gadeiel made after the broadcast is Peter Singer’s in order to fake the car bomb. Peter Singer’s still around… I wonder if he might be living among certain monks with pretty good libraries.

  33. Ninmesara says:

    Assuming it is Sarah inside the Ark, which body does she (it?) want from Gadiriel? The perfect body for people to fall in love with is Gadiriel’s… Can she mind-control an angel? She appears to be able to mind-control Ana. The whole part where she coincidently ends up in San Francisco after running for a long time, and once in San Francisco decides to climb the tower and call the mistral name is very suspicious. They blame it on LSD, but come on… Singing a name that calls the wind near a ship that runs on kabbalah? Too convenient for a simple LSD trip…

  34. “When she spoke on television”

    I assume this was delivered via tape.

    • anon says:

      Couldn’t it be before television stopped working?

      • Sniffnoy says:

        That would be one way of fixing it, yes. Though in that case the text should be changed to reflect that; “When she had spoken on television…”, possibly “Back when she had spoken on television…”

    • Good Burning Plastic says:

      Well, one thing that jarred me about the interlude about the broadcast was the “without any reason to have a TV” part. In such a world after broadcasts stop working I would expect the distribution of VHS tapes to become extremely widespread.

  35. Ben Cass says:

    Typo:

    Missing space: “powers.The” -> “powers. The”

  36. hnau says:

    They say that when you see the Lady, she looks like whoever you love most – love in a purely erotic sense, the single person you’ve felt the strongest moment of sexual attraction towards. It is an awkward spell she casts.

    Prediction / hope: Gadiriel and Ana are going to meet at some point.

  37. Rafe Saltman says:

    Isn’t it funny that Gadiriel told Sarah she could be NE-1?

  38. Sekhmet says:

    Okay, going through a reread since I read way too quickly the first time and missed so many small details.

    Quick mostly irrelevant question about Gadiriel: she looks like whoever somebody’s had the most sexual attraction too. What about for asexuals, especially Ana? Does it flip to most romantic attraction, most aesthetic attraction? Do they see her at all? Would asexual aromantics see her at all either?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *